The bill that started it
July 2023. Our electricity bill came in 34% higher year-over-year. The CFO caught me by the coffee machine: "You manage $1.2M in facilities budget. How does electricity jump 34% without anyone noticing?"
Fair question. I'd tracked every invoice in our procurement system for 6 years. But energy was one category I'd never really torn apart—until the Q2 2023 audit. When I did, two things stood out: our oldest warehouse was running HVAC units from 2008, and we'd never seriously evaluated on-site generation.
So I started looking at solar.
Between September and December 2023, I contacted 8 vendors. Sunrun was one of them. Their quote: a 20 kW rooftop system, 25-year lease, Brightbox battery included, three escalator options—0.9%, 1.9%, and 2.9%.
The sales rep recommended 1.9%. "Balanced option," he said. "Most customers pick this one."
I almost signed. 1.9% is below inflation, I figured. What could go wrong?
The question I couldn't answer
January 2024. Construction notices went up at one of our apartment buildings—the one slated for Sunrun residential solar on its rooftop. A tenant, Dave—retired physics teacher—stopped me in the hallway.
"If our solar system is moving at roughly 450,000 miles per hour around the galaxy," he said, "how does a rooftop panel stay pointed at the sun?"
I mumbled something about fixed tilt angles and wide acceptance angles, then excused myself.
But I went home and started reading.
And I realized a more fundamental problem: I didn't actually understand the technical specs in that quote. Tilt, azimuth, temperature coefficient, annual degradation—all of it was "precisely calculated" by the vendor, and I'd accepted it without question.
If you don't understand the specs, you can't evaluate the quote. I learned this lesson in 2022 with office furniture (ugh, that was a $3,200 mistake because I didn't catch what "commercial grade" actually meant). But with solar, I was about to repeat it.
The next morning, I emailed Sunrun's local installer and asked for the engineering report.
The 34-page report and the 1.9% line
The report was 34 pages. Tilt, string configuration, inverter model, annual production estimates based on PVWatts. I spent two weekends cross-checking the numbers against NREL's public data.
That's when I noticed the escalator details.
Sunrun's three options looked like this (monthly payment, Year 1):
- 0.9% escalator: $245/month
- 1.9% escalator: $228/month
- 2.9% escalator: $208/month
At first glance, 2.9% looks cheapest, right? Lowest starting payment.
I opened my TCO spreadsheet. Total payments over 25 years (excluding buyout, assuming no early termination):
- 0.9%: ~$82,000
- 1.9%: ~$86,500
- 2.9%: ~$89,800
That's a $7,800 spread. Not exactly pocket change.
But here's what surprised me more: the 1.9% option's 25-year total came out almost even with the net savings I calculated using a 2.5% annual utility rate increase. In other words, the "balanced option" the rep recommended wasn't actually optimal over the full term—it just had a lower starting payment, which made it feel friendlier.
That got me re-reading the whole quote.
The battery question
Brightbox battery is included in the lease. Sounds great—home battery installation without an extra line item.
But if the battery is "included," where's its cost?
I asked the installer to break out the battery pricing. They said the lease is a bundled rate, not itemized. Understandable, but from a procurement angle, what I needed wasn't a breakdown—it was an alternative comparison.
Around that time I'd been following home battery storage news in the UK—Octopus Energy's smart tariff restructuring, the Powerwall price reductions across Europe—and seeing payback periods compress. That raised a question: by locking a battery premium into a 25-year lease, was I betting against further battery price drops?
US market data from Q1 2024 (SEIA/Wood Mackenzie) showed residential storage prices down about 6% year-over-year. If that trend held, installing a battery separately in 5 years might cost less than locking the price in now.
I didn't have a definitive answer, but it became a negotiation point.
The buyout clause
Sunrun's lease allows a buyout at Year 5. The buyout price is based on the present value of remaining payments—but the key question is whether the escalator adjustment is included in that base.
Three emails back and forth with their contracts team. Final answer: the Year 5 buyout is calculated on the original monthly payment's remaining present value, with escalator increases excluded from the buyout base.
Which means: if you're planning a mid-term buyout, the low-escalator + higher-starting-payment combination actually works better, because your buyout base is lower.
That detail wasn't on the quote sheet.
What we actually signed
We didn't go with 1.9%.
We chose the 0.9% escalator plus a Year 5 buyout window clause. Starting payment was $17 higher, but the 25-year total saved about $4,500 if held to term—or, if we bought out at Year 5, we'd be locking in a lower base.
One more thing: Sunrun's local installer agreed to take on an 80 kW rooftop section next to our warehouse—a small project that two other vendors had flat-out declined as "too small to quote." I filed that away. Small orders shouldn't be dismissed, and that's probably the deepest lesson from 6 years of procurement: the vendor who takes your $200 trial order seriously is often the one you trust with $20,000 three years later.
What I'd tell the next procurement manager
Three things.
First, the escalator rate needs to be evaluated on the 25-year total, not the Year 1 payment. The number a sales rep recommends is usually the "feels most comfortable" point between starting payment and long-term cost—not the optimal choice.
Second, evaluate the battery separately. If the quote is bundled, ask how the buyout clause handles the battery portion. Battery prices are falling (the UK and European market data makes that pretty clear), and a 25-year lock-in isn't automatically smart.
Third, find a tenant like Dave. An outsider's question—"how does a panel stay pointed at the sun if our solar system is moving?"—forced me to actually read the 34-page engineering report. If you don't understand the specs, you're just trusting the sales pitch.
And I've stopped assuming that below-inflation escalators are automatically a good deal (thankfully, before signing anything).
Ask about this topic